Advertisement

Prevalence of Respiratory Failure and Associated Factors in Adult Intensive Care Unit of Saint Paul’s and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital, Ethiopia 2020

Research Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2835-2882/022

Prevalence of Respiratory Failure and Associated Factors in Adult Intensive Care Unit of Saint Paul’s and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital, Ethiopia 2020

  • Kindalem Gebeyehu Abebe 1*
  • Yohannes Koster 1
  • Melke Bimrew 1

Kindalem Gebeyehu Abebe, St. Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

*Corresponding Author: Kindalem Gebeyehu Abebe, St. Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Citation: Kindalem G. Abebe, Yohannes Koster, Melke Bimrew, (2023), Prevalence Of Respiratory Failure and Associated Factors in Adult Intensive Care Unit of Saint Paul’s and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital, Ethiopia 2020, Clinical Research and Studies, 2(3); DOI:10.31579/2835-2882/022

Copyright: 2023, Kindalem Gebeyehu Abebe. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: 09 June 2023 | Accepted: 19 June 2023 | Published: 27 June 2023

Keywords: prevalence; respiratory failure and associated factors; ethiopia

Abstract

Background: Severe respiratory failure is a common reason for admission to the intensive care unit that occurs for several reasons, including pulmonary disease, neuromuscular disease, shock and the necessity for airway protection or temporary breathing support after major surgery. For patients with ARF, mechanical aeration is the cornerstone of management.

Objective: to assess the prevalence of respiratory failure and associated factors among patients admitted the adult intensive care unit of Saint Paul’s Millennium Medical College and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma hospitals Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2020.

The prevalence of respiratory failure was high. Multiple factors influence the development of respiratory failure. Older age, cardiac disease, Human Immune Deficiency Virus and trauma were at risk of developed respiratory failure Therefore, Health care professionals, policy makers and other concerned bodies should give emphasis to the factors that contribute to the development of respiratory failure. They should give priority especially for older, HIV, cardiac, and trauma patients to provide easily accessible and quality care.

Introduction

Respiratory failure is a disorder, characterized by inability of the respiratory system to support effective and continuous gas exchange. The most common causes of acute respiratory failure are pneumonia, acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), sepsis, asthma, drug ingestion, and trauma. In the aging, pneumonia, heart failure, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), ARDS, and sepsis predominate [1].

Severe respiratory failure is a common reason for admission to the intensive care unit that occurs for several reasons, including pulmonary disease, neuromuscular disease, shock and the necessity for airway protection or temporary breathing support after major surgery. For patients with ARF, mechanical aeration is the cornerstone of management. [2, 3]

The magnitude of acute respiratory failure has become one of the most epidemiological tasks facing today's health systems in all intensive care units around the world.[4] Though, it is difficult to enumerate because the cause of death is more likely to be registered as pneumonia, COPD, or another underlying condition, rather than respiratory failure [5]. Respiratory failure endure a major cause of morbidity and mortality in the intensive care location, RF may be responsible for as many as 10–15% for admissions to medical ICU and for as many as 50–75% of those patients who require ICU stays longer than 7 days [6].

It also grounds numerous complications such as pulmonary embolism, reduced cardiac output, arrhythmias, acute kidney injury, incidence of acute respiratory failure admitted to ICU department is ranged 500 patients in the year 2016 affording to the statistical record of Assiut University Hospital [7].

Despite significant technological advances in mechanical ventilator support, the mortality is considerably high, exceeding 40% in many series [8, 9]. other studies also show, despite advances in the management of ARF with mechanical ventilator, death has not decreased significantly and costs continue high [10, 11].

A prospective cohort study conducted in Brazil showed that, among 1732 enrolled patients, 843 (49%) were admitted to an ICU with ARF and the remaining 889 (51%) patients who were admitted without ARF, 141(8%) developed ARF during their stay in the ICU and among total of ARF case (984),475 (48%) died during the ICU stay [12].

A retrospective study showed by the American Journal of Surgery, patients who developed respiratory failure (21%) had a 42% mortality compared with a 6% mortality in patients who did not develop respiratory failure [13]. A prospective cohort study conducted at the Intensive care department, Saint-Louis Hospital University Paris, among 99 patients were admitted for acute respiratory failure, the 30-day mortality rate was 26.2% [14]

In a descriptive study conducted at Assiut University Hospital, the age of patients, admission category to ICU, and cardiac disease were significantly associated with respiratory failure development [7]. A prospective cohort study conducted at Brazilian showed, patients age, type of ICU admission and length of stay in ICU are significantly associated with respiratory failure [12].

A retrospective descriptive chart review was conducted in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The finding revealed that respiratory failure was the leading complication or immediate cause of death accounts (32.8%) followed by cardiovascular failure (16.1%) [15].

The objective of this research was to assess the prevalence of respiratory failure and associated factors in adult ICU of St. Paul’s Hospitals Millennium Medical College, and AaBET, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Methods And Materials

Method: An institution based retrospective cross-sectional study was conducted from August 26 to September 25, 2020. Among a total of 2198 population, 384 samples were selected using systematic random sampling. A multivariable logistic regression analysis was used to identify predictors of respiratory failure using odds ratio, 95% confidence interval, and p-value < 0>

Study area and period

This study was conducted in Addis Ababa Ethiopia. Addis Ababa is the capital city of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa is administratively divided into ten sub-cities and 116 districts. Data was collected from two hospitals, namely Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital from August 26 to September 25, 2020.Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College is a specialty hospital providing care to the underserved population in the outskirts of Addis Ababa. It currently has 580 beds, with an annual average of 200,000 patients and a catchment population of more than 5 million.

Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital is a newly established 250 bed and 14 ICU bed, teaching and public referral hospital in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, affiliated with St. Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College. Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital provides 24/7 specialty services in emergency medicine, critical care, trauma and acute care surgery, orthopedics, neuro-surgery, and forensic medicine; patients presenting with complaints requiring additional specialty services (example cardiology, gastroenterology) are stabilized and transferred to nearby SPHMMC. There are 40 nurses and 11 mechanical ventilators in ICU.

Sample Size determination

The sample size was estimated using single population proportion formula by assuming the prevalence of respiratory failure is assumed as 50% since there is no previous related study; and desired precision level of 5%, 95% confidence level. For single proportion population,

no= 

 Where, no=sample size, p=prevalence respiratory failure is 50% and d=margin of error (0.05)

Hence, the sample size was calculated as [no= (Zα/2) ²p (1-p) /d2] = (1.96) ²× (0.5x0.5)/ (0.05) ² = 384. Therefore, the final calculated sample size is 384.

Data Collection Procedures and tools

The checklist for this study was adapted with some modification from a research conducted at Assiut University Hospital [7]. It was first translated from English to Amharic and then retranslated back to English by a linguistic graduate to assure its consistency. The checklist was pretested before the actual data collection. The data collectors were two BSc critical care nurses. The principal investigator and the supervisors were checked for missed values and completeness on daily basis.

Data Management and analysis

This data was entered into Epi data 3.1 and export to SPSS version 24 statistical software packages for cleaning and analysis. Binary logistic regression model was fitted to identify the association between independent versus out-come variable. All independent variables with a p-value of 0.25 and less in the bivariable analysis was entered into multivariable logistic regression models in order to identify independent predictors of respiratory failure. Crude and adjusted odd ratios were computed with their corresponding 95% confidence interval. P-value with < 0.05 was used to declare statistical significance of the results.

Socio demographic Information

Among a total, more than half of respondents 193(50.3%) were male. More than half of the respondent’s’ age distribution, 202(52.6%) were between 18–40 years, 37(9.6%) were in the age group of 41–50 years and the remaining 145(37.8%) were above 50 years of age with a mean age of 43.55 ± 19.49 of standard deviation (Table 1).

 

Variables (n = 384)

Frequency

Percent (%)

Age group

 

 

18–40 years

202

52.6

41–50 years

37

9.6

>50 years

145

37.8

Sex

 

 

Male

193

50.3

Female

191

49.7

Table 1: Socio-demographic characteristics of respondents who had admitted ICU from September 2014 to August 2020, at Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College and Addis Ababa Burn Emergency and Trauma (AaBET) Hospital Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2020

Medical, surgical and trauma related characteristics of respondent’s response

This research tried to assess respondent’s admission type, medical, surgical and trauma related characteristics, and their history of diseases condition. In this study the prevalence of respiratory failure was 139(36.2%). Among the total admitted patients, 259(67.4%) were admitted by medical case. Majority of them 319(83.1%) were admitted for the first time. Most of the respondents had history of 291(75.8%) pneumonia, 243(63.3%) sepsis, 209(54.4%) renal and 162(42.2%) cardiac disease respectively (Table 2).

Table 2: Medical, surgical and trauma related characteristics of respondents (n = 384) in adult ICU from September 2014 to August 2020 at SPHMMC and AaBET Hospital Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2020

Variables (n = 384)

Frequency

Percent (%)

History of respiratory failure

 

 

Yes

139

36.2

No

245

63.8

Admission type to ICU

 

 

First time admission

319

83.1

Recurrent admission

65

16.9

History of hypertension

 

 

Yes

139

36.2

No

245

63.8

History of diabetes mellitus

 

 

Yes

65

16.9

No

319

83.1

History of COPD

 

 

Yes

128

33.3

No

256

66.7

History of pneumonia

 

 

Yes

291

75.8

No

93

24.2

History of asthma

 

 

Yes

60

15.6

No

324

84.4

History of tuberculosis (TB)

 

 

Yes

100

26

No

284

74

History of cardiac disease

 

 

Yes

162

42.2

No

222

57.8

History of renal disease

 

 

Yes

209

54.4

No

175

45.6

Case of ICU admission

 

 

Medical

259

67.4

Surgical

73

19

Gynecology

52

13.5

History of sepsis

 

 

Yes

243

63.3

No

141

36.7

Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome

 

 

Yes

193

50.3

No

191

49.7

History of malignancy/lung cancer

 

 

Yes

22

5.7

No

362

94.3

Status of HIV/AIDS

 

 

Reactive

39

10.2

Nonreactive

345

89.8

History of trauma/injury

 

 

Yes

159

41.4

No

225

58.6

History of anemia

 

 

Yes

199

51.8

No

185

48.2

History of pulmonary edema

 

 

Yes

73

19

No

311

81

Hx of pulmonary thrombo embolism (PTE)

 

 

Yes

44

11.5

No

340

88.5

Regarding duration of ICU stay, more than half of respondents 203 (52.9%) were stay in ICU greater than 15 days, 55(14.3%) of them were stay between 11–15 days, whereas 63(16.4%) of them between 5–10 days and the remaining 63(16.4%) were stay less than five (5) days; with a mean duration of 3.04 ± 1.162 of standard deviation (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Figure 1: Duration of stay in adult intensive care unit at Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College and Addis Ababa Burn, Emergency and Trauma Hospital from September.2014 to August 2020.

Factors associated with respiratory failure

In simple binary logistic regression age, duration of ICU stays, COPD, TB, Cardiac disease, Renal disease, Asthma, case of ICU admission, sepsis, ARDS, HIV, pulmonary edema and trauma were significantly associated with respiratory failure at p-value less than 0.25. In multivariable logistic regression age > 50 years, duration of stay > 15 days, COPD, CHD, Asthma, sepsis, HIV and trauma were significant at p-value less than 0.05 and 95% confidence interval.

Age of the respondent was significantly associated with respiratory failure of intensive care unit patient. Patients whose age greater than > 50 years were 5 times more likely to develop respiratory failure than patients whose age between 18–40 years (AOR = 4.88(95%CI: 2.1, 11.4). Patients who stayed more than 15 days of duration in intensive care unit were 76% (AOR = 0.24(95%CI: 0.086,0.65) less likely to develop respiratory failure as compared to the patients who’s stayed less than 5 days duration.

Patients who had history of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease were 2 times more likely develop respiratory failure as compared to patients who had not history of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (AOR = 2.3(95%CI: 1.98, 4.79) (Table 3). Patients who had history of asthma were 77% (AOR = 0.23(95%CI: 0.087, 0.6) less likely to develop respiratory failure compared to patients who had no history of asthma. Patients who got cardiac disease were 3 times more likely to develop respiratory failure as compared to patients who did not have cardiac disease (AOR = 3.01(95%CI: 1.36, 6.66) (Table 3).

Regarding to history of sepsis, patients who had sepsis were 57% (AOR = 0.43(95%CI: 0.2, 0.94) less likely to develop respiratory failure than patients who had no history of sepsis. Patients who were HIV reactive were 4 times more likely to develop respiratory failure as compared to patients who were HIV non-reactive patients (AOR = 4.3(95%CI: 1.34, 13.92). Patients who had history of trauma were 3 times more likely to develop respiratory failure as compared to patients who were had not history of trauma (AOR = 2.93(95%CI: 1.36, 6.35) (Table 3).

 

VariableRespiratory failureCOR(95%CI)AOR(95% CI)P-value
 YesNo   
Age group     
18–40 years34(8.9)168(43.8)11 
41–50 years7(1.8)30(7.8)1.15(0.47,2.84)0.96(0.27,3.37)0.95
> 50 years98(25.5)47(12.2)10.3(6.2,17.1)4.88(2.1,11.4)0.0001**
Duration of stay     
< 5 days20(5.2)43(11.2)11 
5–10 days15(3.9)48(12.5)0.67(0.31,1.47)0.5(0.16,1.51)0.22
11–15 days19(5)36(9.4)1.14(0.53,2.45)1.77(0.63,4.96)0.28
> 15 days85(22.1)118(30.7)1.55(0.85,2.82)0.24(0.086,0.65)0.005**
History of COPD     
Yes74(19.3)54(14.1)4.02(1.5,8.4)2.3(1.98,4.79)0.0001**
No65(17)191(49.6)11 
History of asthma     
Yes13(3.4)47(12.2)0.44(0.23,0.84)0.23(0.087,0.6)0.001**
No126(32.8)198(51.6)1  
TB     
Yes45(11.7)55(14.3)1.65(1.04,2.63)2.03(0.87,4.75)0.1
No94(24.5)190(49.5)11 
Cardiac disease     
Yes98(25.5)64(16.7)6.76(4.26,10.74)3.01(1.36,6.66)0.006**
No41(10.7)181(47.1)11 
Renal failure     
Yes103 (26.9)106 (27.7 )3.86(2.44, 6.11)0.77(0.36,1.64)0.5
No35(9.1)139 (36.3)11 
Cases of admission     
Medical102(26.6)157(40.9)2.16(1.08,4.32)0.84(0.28,2.49)0.75
Surgical25(6.5)48(12.5)1.73(0.78, 3.89)0.97(0.28,3.37)0.95
Gynecology12(3.13)40(10.4)11 
Sepsis     
Yes101(26.3)142(37)1.92(1.23,3.03)0.43(0.2,0.94)0.034**
No38(9.9)103(26.8)11 
ARDS     
Yes94(24.5)99(25.8)3.1(2, 4.77)0.52(0.23,1.15)0.11
No45(11.7)146(38)11 
HIV status     
Reactive20(5.2)19(5)2(1.03,3.9)4.3(1.34,13.92)0.014**
Non-reactive119(31)226(58.8)11 
Trauma     
Yes99(25.8)60(15.6)7.6(4.78,12.2)2.93(1.36,6.35)0.006**
No40(10.4)185(48.2)11 
Pulmonary edema     
Yes32(8.3)41(10.7)1.49(0.89,2.5)1.7(0.74,3.93)0.21
No107(27.9)204(53.1)11 
Where: 1 = reference, ** Significant at p-value of ≤ 0.05

Table 3: Multivariable logistic regression analysis of factors associated with respiratory failure in adult ICU at SPHMMC and AaBET Hospital Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2020

Discussion

Our study aimed to assess the prevalence of respiratory failure and its associated factors using 384 samples among a total of 2198 population admitted in adult intensive care unit from September 2014 to August 2020 at SPHMMC and AaBET Hospital Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

The study reveals that, the prevalence of respiratory failure was 139(36.2%). The finding of this study is lower than the previous studies which was 57% (12) and (58%). (8) However, this study was slightly higher compared than the previous study which was (35%). (16) The difference might be due to methodological variations and differences in sociocultural, economical, health and health provision consumption characteristics between respondents of the referenced areas and the study place.

The finding of our study shows that, respondent’s age category 50 and above were more likely to develop respiratory failure than respondents age category between 18 and 40 years. This study was consistent with the previous three studies. (12, 17, 18)

Regarding to duration in ICU stay, this finding revealed that patients stay fifteen (15) and above were 76% less likely to develop respiratory failure as compared to the patients whose stayed less than 5 days duration. This was in line with a previous study that reported patients stay longer time in ICU increase respiratory failure development. (12, 19) However in contrast with this finding, patients stay in ICU between five and teen were more likely develop respiratory failure. (20) The difference could be due to methodological variation (study design, exclusion and inclusion criteria), sociocultural difference, health service quality and study area.

The present finding revealed that, past history of chronic pulmonary disease, cardiac disorder and trauma was indicated the risk factors associated with respiratory failure. This is agreement with the previous finding. (21) Other studies also compatible with the present study, founded that COPD is the main risk factor of ARF. (20, 22)

Regarding to profile of sepsis, the present study indicated that patients who have sepsis were 57% less likely to develop respiratory failure than patients who had no history of sepsis. This was similar with the previous study which was reported that common risk factors for ARF include sepsis. (23)

This study showed that, patients who have history of asthma were 77% less likely to develop respiratory failure compared to patients who had no history of asthma. This was inconsistent with the previous study. (20) The difference might be due to sociocultural (life style) difference of the population, variation in study area and methodology.

Result

The prevalence of respiratory failure in this study was 139(36.2%).The variables which were significantly associated with respiratory failure were, patients age >50 (AOR =4.88(95%CI: 2.1, 11.4),Duration of stay at intensive care unit >15 days (AOR=0.24(95%CI: 0.086, 0.65), prolonged obstructive pulmonary disease (AOR=2.3 (95%CI: 1.98, 4.79),Asthma (AOR=0.23(95%CI: 0.087, 0.6) , sepsis (AOR= 0.43 (95% CI:0.2,0.94) , cardiac disease (AOR= 3.01(95%CI: 1.36, 6.66)), Human Immune Deficiency Virus (AOR=4.3(95%CI: 1.34, 13.92) and trauma (AOR= 2.93(95%CI: 1.36, 6.35).

Conclusion

This study conducted that, patients with older age, prolonged length of ICU stay and previous history of chronic obstructed pulmonary disease, cardiac disease, asthma, sepsis, status of HIV and trauma have an increased risk of respiratory failure. More attention should be paid to prevent those leading factors in order to minimize the magnitude and the burden of respiratory failure.

Declarations

Ethical consideration

Ethical clearance was obtained from Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College Institute of Health Ethical Review Board. Information about the study was given to the selected participants in order to obtain their written consent before administering the questionnaires. Participants were informed that they have the right to discontinue or refuse to participate in the study. Answers to any question were completely confidential and the privacy of the respondents was maintained.  All methods were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations.

Availability of data and materials

Data will be available upon request from the corresponding author

Competing interests 

The authors declare that they have no competing interests

Funding 

All funding of this original research process covers by all authors 

Funding for Publication 

Not applicable 

Consent for Publication 

Not applicable 

Authors’ contributions

GB, YK and MB were involved in conception, designing methods, analysis, interpretation and drafting of the manuscript. KG and YK were participated in write-up of the manuscript. All authors have reviewed and approved the submission of the manuscript. 

Authors’ detail 

Yohannes Koster: MPH, Public Health expert, Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia 

Melke Bimrew:  MSc in oncology, Lecturer, Department of nursing, Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia

Kindalem Gbeyehu: Department of emergency and critical care, faculty of health science, St. Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia

Acknowledgment We would like to thank Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College for the support for the realization of this finding. Special thanks and appreciation to all those who agreed to participate in this study, mainly respondents, data collectors and supervisors.

References

Clinical Trials and Clinical Research: I am delighted to provide a testimonial for the peer review process, support from the editorial office, and the exceptional quality of the journal for my article entitled “Effect of Traditional Moxibustion in Assisting the Rehabilitation of Stroke Patients.” The peer review process for my article was rigorous and thorough, ensuring that only high-quality research is published in the journal. The reviewers provided valuable feedback and constructive criticism that greatly improved the clarity and scientific rigor of my study. Their expertise and attention to detail helped me refine my research methodology and strengthen the overall impact of my findings. I would also like to express my gratitude for the exceptional support I received from the editorial office throughout the publication process. The editorial team was prompt, professional, and highly responsive to all my queries and concerns. Their guidance and assistance were instrumental in navigating the submission and revision process, making it a seamless and efficient experience. Furthermore, I am impressed by the outstanding quality of the journal itself. The journal’s commitment to publishing cutting-edge research in the field of stroke rehabilitation is evident in the diverse range of articles it features. The journal consistently upholds rigorous scientific standards, ensuring that only the most impactful and innovative studies are published. This commitment to excellence has undoubtedly contributed to the journal’s reputation as a leading platform for stroke rehabilitation research. In conclusion, I am extremely satisfied with the peer review process, the support from the editorial office, and the overall quality of the journal for my article. I wholeheartedly recommend this journal to researchers and clinicians interested in stroke rehabilitation and related fields. The journal’s dedication to scientific rigor, coupled with the exceptional support provided by the editorial office, makes it an invaluable platform for disseminating research and advancing the field.

img

Dr Shiming Tang

Clinical Reviews and Case Reports, The comment form the peer-review were satisfactory. I will cements on the quality of the journal when I receive my hardback copy

img

Hameed khan